Question: DIY Oil Refinery Air Quality Monitoring?

scotttees asked on October 09, 2018 19:13
68 | 2 answers | #17260


Hi All - does anyone have any experience with air quality monitoring, particularly for the types of pollutants being produced by oil/gas refineries. We have this semi-regular thing happening in our neighborhood where there is a strong sulfur odor. I suspect it's from one of the area plants.

What I am interested to do is to set up - DIY style - a routine outdoor air quality monitor, that can help better understand the types of pollutants in the air - particularly the type that come from a refinery. If it could post stats similar to the particulate sensors like PurpleAir.

Thanks in advance!



0 Comments

Log in to comment

2 Answers

This is going to depend on budget, scale and how important real-time emissions and pollutant speciation (whether you want concentrations of all of the compounds or specific ones) is to you or your community. There isn't anything quite like the PurpleAir for tVOCs (total volatile organic compounds) or sulfur compounds in terms of cost vs effectiveness, there are some things that come close, some non-real-time options, and some more pricey options for whole communities to scale up if they work together or with existing organizations like air agencies or non-profit groups. Most of what I know is about VOCs, but I'm not sure if the specific sulfur smell you're experiencing will be detected by a VOC or TRS (total reduced sulfur) or H2S (hydrogen sulfide) sensor.

Before you read below, you may want to consider what your goal is for this monitoring data. You may be able to accomplish the same thing by organizing in your community and reporting smells to the local air agency in your area. Most states have malodor regulations which prohibit facilities from emitting beyond their fencelines. If a facility is violating these regulations you can call and report it, and the more people call, the more chance there will be for a response. If you haven't tried this, I'd highly encourage you to do so before trying to monitor it yourself or contact them in conjunction with monitoring and they may be able to assist you. Getting help from professionals and regulators is a good first step as monitoring can be time consuming and costly, and it's good to exhaust all options.

VOCS

In terms of small scale individual monitors, I'm looking into low-cost real-time VOC monitoring, though there's not too much information about some of the metal oxide sensors currently on the market. I'm hoping to do some collocation testing in the future of the IAQ-Core C, BME680, CCS811, MiCS-VZ-89TE, and SGP30 vs. a photoionization detector (PID). If you have the budget, you may want to check out PID sensors like the Baseline-Mocon eVx, though they can cost upwards of $500 (USD). EPA has an open source sensor based around the Baseline-Mocon PIDs they have been testing around refineries called the S-Pod. I have the documentation for that if you'd like to build it, though it's a relatively expensive project at upwards of $1,500.

Many common community methods you'll see are centered around capturing emissions through grab samples using Tedlar bags or SUMMA canisters (e.g. the Louisiana Bucket Brigade). I think there's some information on Public Lab about the Bucket Brigade and how to do your own grab sampling. This plus lab analysis can be pricey, though some local organizations will lend SUMMA canisters.

I know @ottinger has some expertise in community monitoring, especially around refineries. There are other options that range in price, like open path monitoring using UV-DOAS or FTIR, though for an individual those will be largely outside of your price range. For a community monitoring program with a university, air agency, or other partnership these may be feasible, though come with their own set of advantages and disadvantages. You may be able to do a right to know law request for the refinery in question and get refinery rule data from the refinery's fenceline, though this will only be 2 week benzene data and the averaging times may not be ideal.

Sulfur

In terms of sulfur monitoring, there are some low-cost H2S sensors, which may be what you're smelling, though as far as I know they are largely untested. I believe there was another Public Lab project somewhere on measuring H2S, I think this is it. Someone may have been using badges to measure it, not sure if there's something more real-time-concentration-based.

Here is a list of H2S regulations. I think most of this would be measured professionally using method 16-b but you may have to again submit a right to know request to your local or state air agency to get this information, if it has been measured locally.

Sorry for the length of this response, if you have further questions or need clarification on anything here, let me know.


Thanks again for a super helpful and through posting Karl! I'm just going to ping @sara (whose work you mention in your note) to see if she has any additional ideas about H2S.


Hi @scotttees ! There are a couple people I've been talking to recently who have been working with the Purple Air: @dswenson @jiteovien @Ag8n @ramseysprague They might be able to help with insight on that tool.

Also sulfur is a pretty noxious pollutant. Might be interesting to loop in with people who are working on odor reporting: @imvec and @sarasage

And just for the topic in general @eustatic and @a1ahna might have some ideas!


Also @guolivar posted this great page on the Purple Air https://publiclab.org/notes/guolivar/01-08-2018/thoughts-on-low-cost-air-quality-sensors

and @BrandonFeenstra from South Coast Air Quality Management District has shared some really helpful resources on this question you might want to check out. https://publiclab.org/questions/warren/01-04-2018/how-good-is-the-purpleair-sensor-and-what-does-it-detect


Log in to comment

From @ottinger on the air quality list "Unfortunately, to my knowledge there are few sensors comparable to the Purple Air for oil refinery pollution--specifically, sensors that can produce readings for toxic gases (e.g. hydrogen sulfide, which is of concern around refineries) in real time.

In Benicia, CA, we experimented some with the AWAIR (about a $200 instrument) but that only reads total VOCs, not individual gases. We also found it more difficult to access data than with the Purple Air (no API) and hard to keep online. (folks in Pittsburgh have more extensive experience with these, and have also found that the absolute values creep up over time)

I believe some of my colleagues in Northern CA are investigating the possibility of using OPSIS systems for this purpose, but I don't know how expensive they are or how amenable to a DIY approach.

The best instrument I know of for this purpose is the UV Hound by Argos Scientific. They monitor the toxic gases of concern around oil refineries, in real time, at reasonably low detection limits, and they aren't terribly hard to use--you have to be able to calibrate them and manage the data upload to a laptop, but there are no moving parts to the monitor itself. They aren't cheap (a couple thousand dollars, I think), so you couldn't spread them throughout a neighborhood, but they are portable, and I'm almost certain that you could rent one for a while for less, if it would be helpful to do a study of a limited duration.

If you were willing to take samples instead, there are additional strategies you could use, especially the "bucket" air sampler.

Hope that helps!"


Log in to comment

Sign up or Login to post an answer to this question.