Want to talk about soil? Join us for Open Call every Tuesday until Mar. 30 and our kick-off call on this topic on Feb. 2! Click here for details on how to join!

Public Lab Research note

How to interpret soil test results

by DanielleS | April 12, 2019 21:04 12 Apr 21:04 | #19047 | #19047

image descriptionMeasurements

Your soil test results are often given as parts per million (ppm) of the contaminant being measured. A value of 1 ppm means that for every million "parts" of soil by dry weight, there would be 1 part of the contaminant. On some soil tests, levels of metals are described in units of "µg/g", essentially meaning "micro-grams per gram," or "mg/kg" (milligrams of contaminant per kilogram of soil), which are both the same as ppm.

The number you see beside each type of contaminant you tested for is telling you the "total" concentration of that contaminant in that soil sample. This does give you a sense of what to watch out for, but is not the full picture because there are many factors which impact how much of that contaminant will be available to be taken into your body and cause harm. We will explore this more later.

So is my soil contaminated?

To understand this, you will need to compare the contaminant concentrations in your soil with the 'screening levels' or 'allowable limits' for each contaminant tested. Sometimes the lab will include the screening limits for various land uses in your results. Various agencies, including the Environmental Protection Agency, have published soil quality guidelines to help protect environmental and human health. These allowable limits or screening levels vary greatly by agency, country, state, and even city. It is interesting to consider why. In the US, polluting industries have a strong lobby and frequently push for the relaxation of environmental regulation and limits on their pollution. Why is it acceptable for soils in Kansas to have higher levels of Benzene than California? Given known toxicological data about the effects of exposures to lead through urban gardening, why are the allowable levels 4x higher in the US than in Canada?

The maximum acceptable level is the highest concentration at which diverse health effects cannot be seen in the exposed receptor. Soil that is considered contaminated is soil which has levels of a element or chemical that are higher than these guidelines for a certain type of land use (residential, agricultural, industrial, recreational, etc). Soil screening levels or limits are based on the exposure pathways of concern at the site (e.g., ingestion). The US EPA classifies land use in these ways:

(1) "Unrestricted use" -- includes vegetable gardens

(2) "Residential use" -- housing

(3) "Restricted use" -- includes commercial (industrial) and recreational sites.

We compared soil contaminant guidelines from various states, countries and agencies below.

Total concentrations vs actual risk

Allowable levels of lead are often given at 100-400 ppm, but given a soil lead level of 100 ppm, eating approximately two teaspoons of this soil per week would be required to give the same amount of lead found in a diet that can cause elevated blood levels of concern. However, when you see that your soil has 140 ppm Lead, this is the total lead found in the soil sample, not the amount of lead that is available to get into your plants or your body and affect your health. Further, we cannot assume that metals are in one of the most toxic and available chemical forms, which is not always the case with metals and other contaminants in soil. For example, hexavalent chromium, or "chromate," is highly toxic to humans. However, total chromium is usually almost entirely in the less toxic form of trivalent chromium.

The behavior of contaminants in the environment, tendency to be taken up by plants, and potential for health effects of human exposure to those metals depend on their chemical form. For example, some forms of metals can readily dissolve in water (soluble) and therefore can enter plants or the human body more easily than forms that cannot easily dissolve (insoluble). Human and plant toxicity depend upon the amount of metal that enters the body or plant-- this has to do with what is called "bioavailability."

To learn more about how to test soil, see Cornell Waste Management Institute Guide to Soil Testing and Interpreting Results.

To learn more about various soil contaminants, and how they act in soils, check out: https://publiclab.org/wiki/soil

image description

I did this Help out by offering feedback!

People who did this (0)

None yet. Be the first to post one!


Login to comment.