| Author | Comment | Last activity | Moderation | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "Thanks @sagarpreet. I have started looking at them. " | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| sagarpreet | "Hi @warren , @bansal_sidharth2996 ! FB has done some major changes in their API endpoints and for Facebook Login . See this : https://developers...." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "Yeah, that would be better to have some of the fields in by the provider and the rest the user can fill in and then can sign up via the provider. T..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| warren | "I like that a lot. And for usernames -- we could prompt for username like warren1 based on a best-guess -- github and twitter have usernames (if th..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "Ok We can do one thing, fb, google and GitHub provides us the email so we can save a random username like warren1 and password. For twitter, let's ..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| warren | ""signup through providers" means a first-timer coming to the site and wanting to interact but not yet having an account, and creating an account by..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "Hi @liz thanks for reviewing my proposal. I have made the flow chart. The workflow is as under 1)The client first of sign up through our https://p..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| liz | "Ah, not sure about "signup through providers" as @bansal_sidharth2996 highlights. To @warren's question about sequence, i agree. We need to have so..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "they go through the minimal barrier-to-entry login and get to what they initially want to do which could be to leave a comment or ask a question. T..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "Also, in case of FB, GitHub and google if we are wishing to have signed up directly with the providers we need to make usernames. I believe that as..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| warren | "Yes, I think that makes sense and it's why i like the option of telling people "please enter an email in case you get locked out of your account" ..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "Yeah I want to point out that 1 )A user is having different emails for different providers. So, that way the new user will sign up via different ac..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "@ebarry thanks. @warren thanks for reviewing my proposal. I want to list some further concerns : 1) we could just allow accounts to not have email..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| liz | "Hi all! What a great thread, i have learned a lot. I also wanted to say how impressive your stats at https://www.stopstalk.com/user/profile/bansal..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| warren | "As to multiple accounts being made, perhaps we need to consider the possibility of a "merge account" system. With the above considerations, and as..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| warren | "OK - some VERY good points here. Great thinking. Let me address what I can: if the twitter username collides with an existing PL username, we cou..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "@warren we need to ignore one or the other problem while deciding about the OAuth. Expecting that problem might not occur. So your suggestions are ..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "Thanks @sagarpreet for your suggestions. One thing I would to say, we should have symmetry with the providers. All providers should be able to be l..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| sagarpreet | "Hi @bansal_sidharth2996 ! You have provided amazing corner-cases in the comments above ! I agree that Twitter does not provide the email , hence..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "@thanks @vidit ,@sukhbir. I will. " | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| sukhbir | "@bansal_sidharth2996 this is a very nice proposal!! I specially loved your implmentation details. Also I have a suggestion for you, it would be mor..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| vidit | "The proposal looks very good and well explanatory. Nice work @bansal_sidharth2996 " | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "Hi @warren, I would like to mention that we cannot have a direct sign up from the provider(without signing through registration form) because of ma..." | Read more » | about 6 years ago | |||
| bansal_sidharth2996 | "For me, markdown button will also give the missing research note. So, I am maintaining a google doc. " | Read more » | about 6 years ago |