Public Lab Research note


  • 7

Sensing Hydrogen Sulfide from CAFO Emissions in Poweshiek County, Iowa

by sophie |

sophie was awarded the Empiricism Barnstar by Shannon for their work in this research note.


Background

In Poweshiek County, Iowa, there are over 45 confined animal feeding operations, and due to their waste management strategies emissions from the manure, including hydrogen sulfide, often become airborne and reach people living in adjacent communities. The legal limit of hydrogen sulfide in Poweshiek County is 30 ppb for one hour up to seven times per year, and this summer a research group from the University of Iowa is monitoring H2S levels at nearby homes to determine whether levels are in fact within those permitted by the law. As a part of my contribution to this project, I am evaluating whether the DIY photographic paper method of H2S sampling originally designed by Claire Horwell et al. can be applied to CAFO emissions, specifically at levels at or below 30 ppb. I will deploy my samplers side-by-side with the conventional passive samplers in order to calibrate them. It is my hope that, if this method is successful, people living near CAFOs will be able to easily collect reliable data to find out whether they are at any risk from H2S exposure.

Goals

• Determine if and how well this method can be applied to CAFO emissions, especially at or below 30 ppb • Find a relatively easy method of quantifying data • Create maps of H2S emissions, possibly using MapKnitter • Promote method to communities to crowd-source H2S monitoring

Making and Light-proofing the Samplers

To make the samplers, I followed the procedure described by Horwell et al. and posted on other Wikis. The only alteration I made was that instead of hanging each strip to dry on a clothespin, I left them face-up on a bed of paper towels for >12 hours, due to lack of a private darkroom. I then needed a way to deploy them in the field such that light could not reach them but air could, so I designed an air sampling box that contains a series of baffles that allow air but not light in:

DSCN0529.JPG

I cut a hole the size of the lid of a film canister into the bottom of a 4"x4"x4" box.

DSCN0527.JPG

baffle_template.pdf

I designed a baffle template that folds into the box and is taped into place (photo is oriented so front face is on the left). It is cut out of black poster stock to minimize light in the box.

DSCN0539.JPG DSCN0531.JPG

Baffle is folded and taped into place with black duct tape. Rope caulk does a good job of filling cracks at the seams.

DSCN0551.JPG

The back corner can accommodate up to two samplers (best if taped into place).

DSCN0563.JPG

Light-proofed! Once the box is sealed shut with more black duct tape, only air can get to the samplers.

As for rain-proofing, if I cannot place the boxes in sheltered areas I plan to cover them each with a plastic plate or bowl.

Testing at Low Concentrations of H2S

I am currently doing a trial run to test whether the samplers can, under laboratory conditions, detect H2S levels at or below 30 ppm. I obtained 6 25-gallon emergency water storage bags and placed two treated photo paper strips in each (film canisters wouldn’t fit through the openings). Each bag was then filled with 0, 5, 10, 20, 30, or 50 ppb of H2S, shaking them every day to ensure even gas distribution. After two weeks, I retrieved and fixed the paper to determine if any darkening has occurred. The results seem to indicate that either this technique is not sensitive enough to detect such low levels of H2S, or that this method of testing was problematic (picture below). I'd like to think it was the latter, as the way the H2S was transferred to the bags could not have been perfectly airtight. It is also possible that despite using rubber stoppers and corks, some gas may have escaped out of the bag during shaking or even just while sitting under the hood. Finally, because the samplers were jostling around for two weeks, their coating may have worn off, or they could have rested face-down against the bag, which would have prevented H2S detection.

DSCN0570.JPG

Water storage bags holding samplers and low concentrations of H2S

Screen_Shot_2014-07-24_at_3.43.59_PM.png

Samplers exposed to low concentrations of H2S for two weeks in water storage bags

Small-Scale First Trial: Inside of a Hog Confinement Facility

A nearby hog farmer graciously allowed me to place three samplers in his confinement barn of 1,200 head. After two weeks, I retrieved two of the samplers, as well as one I set up outside my house in a residential area as a control. I found visible changes in the photo paper, but because the discoloration is cumulative over two weeks it does not indicate that the levels of H2S in the barn are any higher than normal. At this point, I can only confirm that this method shows promise with confined animal feeding operations.

Screen_Shot_2014-07-18_at_1.28.23_PM.png

Control (left) and test (center and right) samplers after two weeks of exposure.

Large-Scale Testing

The researchers at the University of Iowa are recruiting volunteers who live within one mile of a CAFO in Poweshiek County. I will deploy 40 of my samplers side-by-side with those of the University of Iowa (Sigma-Aldrich radiello radial diffusive samplers) at the homes of the recruits. Each box will contain one sampler from Batch A and one from Batch B, and will remain in place for 14 days, after which time I will retrieve and fix the samplers.

Quantification and Analysis

Horwell et al. used spectrofluorimetry to quantify the amount of sulfide collected in each sampler, but this method requires access to a laboratory and is therefore not realistic for civic science. Instead, I am currently working with quantification of color intensity using the free software ImageJ, which would only require scanning of the test strips. Instructions can be found here (scroll down): http://support.dalton.missouri.edu/index.php/wiki/Public:Quantifying_Color_Intensity/

Screen_Shot_2014-07-15_at_3.42.47_PM.png

I tested out this method using an (inverted) image from Horwell et al. and was quite pleased with the result.

References:

Horwell, C.J., A.G. Allen, T.A. Mather, and J.E. Patterson. 2004. Evaluation of a novel passive sampling technique for monitoring volcanogenic hydrogen sulfide. J. Environ. Monit. 6: 630-635.

Horwell, C.J., J.E. Patterson, J.A. Gamble, and A.G. Allen. 2005. Monitoring and mapping of hydrogen sulfide emissions across an active geothermal field: Rotorua, New Zealand. Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research 139: 259-269.

Iowa Department of Natural Resources. 2004. Animal Feeding Operations Field Study. Appendix C: Iowa Administrative Code 567 Chapter 32. http://www.iowadnr.gov/Portals/idnr/uploads/air/environment/afo/appendix_c.pdf.


Post your attempt to replicate this activity 


Replications (0)

None yet. Be the first to post one!



This is marked this as an activity for others to try.
Try it now   Click here to add some more details.


hydrogen-sulfide-sensing hydrogen-sulfide air-quality h2s hydrogen-sulfide-testing cafo h2s-photopaper

barnstar:empiricism activity:h2s activity:h2s-photopaper

5 Comments

Wow, this looks great; I really appreciate the emphasis on ease of construction and your careful water bag tests! @megan, @deepwinter, and others who've published on this kind of h2s detection will be thrilled.


Nice! I love the water bag tests, it is really brilliant. What is the cost of the bags? If doing a large scale deployment, it seems like it would be pretty low-cost to run this quantifying control at the same time as the field experiment, with the same strips, ect. I can't wait to see the results! Thanks for posting the link on the analysis as well. I have used the histogram analysis method in Photoshop to quantify color intensity in aerial images and found it works somewhat, but the accuracy is not that great especially when you have really similar tones. However, I have only used the data to demonstrate total percentages of land use/cover/ect. I am definitely going to see if graphing the numbers makes a difference in the accuracy/understanding of the data. It seems like a simple program could be written to do this automatically too! Fantastic, thank you:]


Thanks for all the positive feedback! I'm not sure where the bags originally came from, but they cost about $35 for five here: http://beprepared.com/basic-25-gallon-boxed-water-kit.html The concern I have with the technique is whether jostling the strips around freely within the bags will smear off their coating and affect their discoloration, but I'll find out in a week and post an update!


Hi Sophie it just occurred to me that the Hydrogen Sulfide may have reacted with the metallic surface of the bag? Did you consider that? What were they made of?


Hi, Sophie - did you get to do your follow-up tests? I'm curious what's happened since you published this! Thanks!


You must be logged in to comment.