Public Lab Research note


MidOpt Dual Bandpass and Event38 filter testing

by Claytonb |

Read more: publiclab.org/n/12636


I recently had Jason Dougherty with Midwest Optical Systems (MidOpt) send me some of their new Dual Bandpass filters and wanted to share some of the results and get any input. My application is in crop imaging and NDVI processing. I have been using the Event38 NGB filter (Event38) which is a cutoff filter that filters out the red light and passes near infrared instead. The blue and green channels collect their light respectively along with NIR. It has a very wide color band. The Dual Bandpass filters have a much narrower bands and are centered at specified wavelengths with the visible channel collecting NIR as well. These are two different types of filters but I thought I would compare them with each other. The MidOpt DB 475/850 more closely matches the Event38 filter in terms of band usage. The filters are mounted internally in Canon S100’s in place of the original IR filter. The Event38 filter size is 8.9X7.9X0.5 mm and the MidOpt filters are 8.9X7.9X1 mm. Both filters are thicker than the factory IR filter. The sensor screws are backed out approximately ¾ turn each from the factory position after replacing the factory IR filter and then fine adjusted in order to correct focus. These are uncalibrated images all taken with f/4, Exp 1/1000, ISO 100. White balance for the Event 38 and DB 475/850 are set with the camera’s cloudy setting and the DB 660/850 white balance is set with a piece of red construction paper in the shade. The next step is to compare calibrated images with targets of known reflectance values using Ned Horning's calibration plugin for ImageJ/Fiji (Neds Plugin)

MidOpt DB475/850 transmission graph,JPEG, and separate channels with NDVI channel comparison

475-850_Transmission_Graph.png

JPEG

475-850_jpeg.JPG

DB475/850 Blue Channel

475-850_jpeg.JPG_(blue).jpg

DB475/850 Green Channel

475-850_jpeg.JPG_(green).jpg

DB475/850 Red Channel

475-850_jpeg.JPG_(red).jpg

DB475/850 VIS blue NIR red

475-850_VIS_Red_NIR_Blue.jpg

DB475/850 VIS green NIR red

475-850_VIS_Red_NIR_Green.jpg

Event38 transmission graph, JPEG, and separate channels with NDVI channel comparison

Event38_Transmission_Graph.jpg

JPEG

Event38IMG_7925.JPG

Event38 Blue Channel

Event38IMG_7925.JPG_(blue).jpg

Event38 Green Channel

Event38IMG_7925.JPG_(green).jpg

Event38 Red Channel

Event38IMG_7925.JPG_(red).jpg

Event38 VIS green NIR red

Event38VIS_Blue_NIR_Green.jpg

Event38 VIS blue NIR red

Event38VIS_Blue_NIR_Red.jpg

MidOpt DB660/850 transmission graph, JPEG, and separate channels with NDVI channel comparison

660-850_Transmission_Graph.png

JPEG

660-850_jpeg.JPG

DB660/850 Blue Channel

660-850_jpeg.JPG_(blue).jpg

DB660/850 Green Channel

660-850_jpeg.JPG_(green).jpg

DB660/850 Red Channel

660-850_jpeg.JPG_(red).jpg

DB660/850 VIS red NIR blue

660-850_VIS_Blue_NIR_Red.jpg

DB660/850 VIS red NIR green

660-850_VIS_Green_NIR_Red.jpg


2 Comments

@Claytonb, thanks for the test. I assume the images are correct but the channels in the image captions are somehow mixed up. I guess it should be:

DB475/850 VIS: blue IR: green or red

Event38 VIS: blue or green IR: red

DB660/850 VIS: red IR: blue or green

Best regards, Thorsten


@Thorsten - you are correct the images were mislabeled. Thanks for the heads up. I have corrected the labels. Thanks again, Clayton


You must be logged in to comment.

Public Lab is open for anyone and will always be free. By signing up you'll joined a diverse group of community researchers and tapped into a lot of grassroots expertise.

Sign up